28 November 2021 by Mondo2.0
The involution of Social Networks (and social users)
The outage of the “social” services WhatsApp, Facebook and Instagram on October 4, 2021 caught all of us somewhat by surprise. How is it possible that these services, always available to everyone, day and night, where we can say everything that crosses our minds, suddenly go offline?
If we think about it, these are spaces that can be used free of charge, have existed for only a decade, and have always been active and functioning, completely at our disposal. Perhaps we are asking the wrong question. We should ask ourselves why these social networks worked continuously for a decade, rather than why they suddenly went “out of service” on October 4.
Such a significant service stoppage made us reflect.
What is the current state of Social Networks (Zuckerberg’s)?
What is our relationship with Social Networks after a decade of use?
Ten years ago, on this Blog, we began describing these new communication spaces to you. We explained the process of “virtualization” of our lives and of our personal network of acquaintances. The strengths: ease of use, free access and freedom of speech, the extreme ease of reaching any node in the network (and of being reached). Factors that would make Social Networks extremely popular and accessible to everyone. Also on this Blog, we highlighted how Facebook had made it possible to demonstrate Milgram’s “six degrees of separation theory”. Evidence of the communicative and social power expressed by these new networks.
And today?
Usability and Interface. In our opinion, the interface and ways of using social networks have not evolved: the structure of Facebook’s web page, Instagram’s presentation of images, and WhatsApp’s chat have remained substantially the same. They are sequential spaces where, to communicate, it is necessary to select, write, click, add, … what was initially proposed certainly already represented a good point of arrival, but it is evident that in a decade there has been no further qualitative leap in terms of use. A user who, paradoxically, used Facebook only in 2010 would find today’s interface familiar. Almost nothing has changed.
The cloning of Influencers. Again, in our very personal opinion, ways of communicating—written text, audio, video and hashtags—have progressively normalized and become standardized. The initial whirlwind of creativity has partly faded; the Instagram or Facebook pages of “Influencers” seem to clone one another, repeating the same presentation patterns. “Influencers” resemble each other and consequently users also clone one another. Content loses personality and intensity in thousands of attempts at replication. One only has to open Facebook (or Instagram) for a few moments to admit the obvious: we are submerged by utterly banal memes.
But the real mix that has caused the involution of social networks is essentially due to three factors: the lack of digital education, the polarization of content, and the use of written text. Let us analyze them one at a time:
The Internet spread quickly, without manuals, without rules, without codes of conduct. The lack of digital education has led cyberusers not to fully perceive the consequences of online exposure—personal data, images and comments. We are the first generation of users; we were not prepared to spend a large part of our time online. We are completely lacking in digital education.
For some strange reason, the cyberuser has a bipolar behavior online. Either they show the best of themselves, even with excessive do-goodism, or they vent all their frustrations online. This second dynamic worries us a great deal. Social networks have become “polarized” spaces. Our social networks, born as spaces for conversation and entertainment, have turned into virtual places where people insult and quarrel. We have learned terms such as “hate speech”, troll, haters. Do you want to publish intolerant expressions, extreme positions on divisive topics, conspiracy theories? Go to social media. These dysfunctional dynamics have clear effects in the real world as well. This is not good at all.
The use of written text in chat and the absence of “face-to-face” contact favor the polarization described above. Write, write, write… but about what? If I no longer have anything to write, I can attract attention with fake news or by taking an extreme position on a highly controversial topic; I will immediately find someone who thinks like me and another thousand who think the opposite. The greatest limitation of social networks today lies in the two-dimensional nature of the context. There are “only” two dimensions; the tools offered are too “poor” considering the number of people involved, the emotions they want to share online, and the time they spend online.
To all this we add that the entropy present online makes every statement plausible and, at the same time, impossible to prove.
To summarize:
- The servers suddenly stop for a few hours on October 4, 2021.
- The two-dimensional, text-based “social” interface has not evolved over the last decade.
- Cyberusers, in the absence of a path of “digital education”, are increasingly polarized and uninhibited.
- Billions of people are online, but they do not have much that is new to say.
Mr. Zuckerberg, aware of this evident involution, strengthened also by the substantial wealth accumulated through the network and spurred on by the server outage, immediately decided to relaunch.
A true “stage coup”: his Facebook 2.0, namely “Meta”.
With “Meta”, the Internet is no longer a two-dimensional virtual universe characterized by limits of use, visibility and interaction, but becomes a true three-dimensional “universe”. A new way of perceiving the Internet, of being on the Internet 100%.
Will it really be like this?
And above all, if traditional social networks have had a disruptive effect on our free time and our social fabric, what will happen in three dimensions?
We will try to answer these questions in our next article, entirely dedicated to the metaverse. For now, the only certainty is that, in the absence of alternatives, social networks (and the social users who use them) will become, over the next decade, the ideal place for prolonged virtual brawls.
We thought that with “social” networks we had created new agoras; we created new gladiatorial arenas.
Mondoduepuntozero
And Twitter? We find it suggestive that many users, suddenly suffering withdrawal on October 4, 2021, moved to Twitter on the wave of the #facebookdown web trend. There is always something to learn about the behavior of cyberusers and their need to “be” constantly online.
